22 Feb The Problem With the WHI finding that Hormone replacement is dangerous
The biggest myth I hear most often: HRT causes breast cancer
Nerd alert! This post is for all of you out there that want to get a little nerdy and learn more about the study that alarmingly and wrongly declared that HRT causes breast cancer. Blame it on the Women’s Health Initiative (WHI). If you haven’t heard of WHI, it was a long-term study evaluating the effects of estrogen, and progestin therapy (E+P), and estrogen-alone therapy (ET) on the risk of cardiovascular disease, cancer, osteoporosis, disability, and poor quality of life in postmenopausal women. The study had two components: the E+P trial for women with intact uteruses, and the ET trial for women who’d had hysterectomies. The big deal about this study is that in 2002, they released a statement saying that the study was stopped due to an increased risk of breast cancer, coronary heart disease, stroke, and pulmonary heart disease. This caused an immediate stop to doctor’s recommending the use of HRT and to this day, many still believe that HRT causes breast cancer. Who hasn’t heard “estrogen causes breast cancer?” or that “HRT is dangerous?” Well, it’s not so black and white.
Problems with the WHI findings:
The findings were not statistically significant:
See, I told you it was going to get nerdy! For findings not to be statistically significant is a very big deal. It means that it can’t be ruled out that the outcome was caused by something other than chance. In research, we want findings to be statistically significant because it means that the likelihood that the relationship between two or more variables is caused by something other than chance. This is what you want!
The findings of one component (E +P) was generalized to all
Researchers indicated that those with an intact uterus and, therefore, on E+P, had a small increased risk for breast cancer. Those without a uterus (on ET), had no increased risk. But the findings were generalized and overdramatized.
The study population was not an accurate representation menopausal women but findings were still generalized to apply to all menopausal women:
- The average age of participants was 63, which of course is long after the onset of menopause.
- Participants were not healthy. 70% of them were seriously overweight or obese, 50% were smokers, and 30% had high blood pressure.
The choice to use HRT is a very personal one. There are many benefits and some risks associated with the use of HRT. You can read more about that here.
Stay curious, unafraid, and armed with knowledge!
-Dr. Maria Luque